If there's one genre of music I highly regret buying too much of, it's late-90s ska-punk.
We all remember how oversaturated the market was back then, with indy bands playing punk-with-horns with upstrokey guitar.
While there were and remain some excellent bands that came out of that era the majority were just terrible bands who were just playing the flavour-of-the-day, much in the same way all the indy bands these days play "screamo."
When it boils down to it, ska-punk bands were classified as "jokey-silly" bands and those that took the lyrics seriously even if the shows were goofy for entertainment's sake.
Over the years, I've been either, selling back the silly bands' CDs or keeping them and just not listening to them.
Here's some of the bands whose albums I used to own or still do. The ratings are:
**** Will buy all CDs
*** Will buy some or have CDs burned for me, if possible
** Will only have CDs burned for me
* Would be interested in selling their CDs.
**** Voodoo Glow Skulls - One of the bands who I just couldn't get into early on, whose stage show made them one of my all-time favourites. I own every VGS CD and have no plans of selling back any of them.
** Mustard Plug - A band with only two good albums (Big Daddy Multitude and Evildoers Beware). They were about half-way between silly and serious lyric-wise and their shows never disappointed.... OK, maybe the last time I saw them, when they had a bunch of women in slutty cop outfits, that was disappointing, because they're way better than that.
*** Reel Big Fish - If it weren't for their excellent musicianship, I'd have left these guys a long time ago. This is a band that sings fun, silly lyrics, but sometimes I'm left wanting some substance.
**** Spring Heeled Jack - These guys released one album that I thought was excellent (Static World View) until their second record came out (Songs from Suburbia). SFS totally blew SWV out of the water. SFS was a rock'n'roll record with horns that sometimes deviated to ska and after hearing that and seeing them live, I wish they'd have stayed together. Their drummer's untimely death probably sealed the band's fate, though.
* Skankin' Pickle - Part of me thinks the reason I bought all their albums was because they were universally loved by people who listened to ska. Truth be told, they were awful. It was just too Sesame Street for me. Highly overrated band.
**** Mighty Mighty Bosstones - Couldn't initially get into them because of Dickie's voice sounding like Cookie Monster (speaking of Sesame Street). I'll admit, my first Bosstones record was Let's Face It, which of course, was the one that got them all the MTV time. I still believe all their records from Question The Answers to Jackknife to a Swan were their best.
**** Less Than Jake - My all-time favourite band, who puts out the greatest record ever made every time. In With The Out Crowd was almost universally panned, but it remains my favourite disc. And my least favourite LTJ record is Pezcore, which is many people's favourite. Go figure. Talk about a band that was able to progress thoughout the years...
** Telegraph - Were among one of the bands I saw open for someone else. When it comes down to it, they were very forgettable. I hung onto their two CDs for sentimental reasons, maybe.
* MU330 - Really got into them for a week or two. At one point, I owned all their records, but then dumped all but the Japan-only release of their Greatest Hits and Chumps on Parade, which was a rock record. They went back to silly ska songs after they dumped that singer, which made me leave the ship.
* Link 80 - With Nick Traina, these guys were my number two favourite band. After Nick's death, I still went and saw them a couple times, as they were still playing his songs. When they released the very metal, The Struggle Continues, my struggle with their sound ended. That CD is out of my collection, but the first two records remain. And I still think I know all the words to Killing Katie.
** Kemuri - I saw this Japanese band on the Ska Against Racism tour and fell in love with them. Bought the Roadrunner-released Little Playmate and played it all the time. The second record was very forgettable and was sold back when I could find a willing victim.
*** Mad Caddies - I really don't know how I fell off their bandwagon. I first heard of them on the Honest Don's Welcome Wagon comp and bought Quality Soft Core when it came out. It had some silly songs, but like Reel Big Fish, the musicianship was very very good. Duck and Cover had some good songs, but it kinda left me feeling underwhelmed. I have not heard anything by this band since.
**** Blue Meanies - One of my other all-time faves, they started as a weird ska-type band and got weirder, incorporating all kinds of music into their sound. They couldn't even shake me from my fandom when their major label release, The Post Wave, came out sounding very poppy. They are teasing a box set which may come out in a couple years. You better believe I'll be first in line for that.
** The Aquabats - Saw them open without knowing anything about them years ago. Was impressed enough to buy the first three records, but the third record was sold back instantly. Their silly songs were catchy enough that I've kept the first two CDs, but have hardly listened to them. In fact, just a few weeks ago, The Return of the Aquabats got stuck in my home CD player when I tried to listen to it. Maybe that was an omen.
** Buck-o-Nine - A friend got me into them, but they really weren't that good. I sold back a couple of their CDs while retaining two. I'd be interested in hearing their newest stuff.
*** Pietasters - This band really hasn't done anything for me, but I enjoy the three or so CDs I do own of theirs.
* Lets Go Bowling - I have all of their albums. Any takers? A pseudo-serious ska band that didn't quite have the chops. Again, anyone interested?
* Bim Skala Bim - Another overrated Moon Ska band. That said, Vinny Nobile was an excellent trombone player, probably the best in ska. Not his fault his bandmates couldn't write any decent music.
**** The Pilfers - speaking of Vinny Nobile, this was the band he formed with Coolie Ranx. They were an opening act for Reel Big Fish and I instantly became a fan. It was more like dancehall-punk with Coolie's vocals. This was probably one of the bands that got me so heavy into reggae.
**** Hepcat - Just an excellent traditional ska band. You can't go wrong with them, as they were about the closest thing to old school ska, like Toots.
**** New York Ska-Jazz Ensemble - I like ska and I like jazz. Nothing better than instrumental ska band covering jazz standards.
*** Slapstick - The amount of bands their breakup spawned is incredible, but they aren't as amazing as everyone would have you believe.
* Suicide Machines - One very very good record, followed by a good record, followed by crap, crap and more crap.